# Avoid Direct Payments: Why Cash Can Hurt the Action You Want

> Money, discounts and gift cards can get people to act, but they can also turn a choice into a paid job that stops the moment the payment stops.

**In short:** A direct payment is a reward of money, or something like it, given straight after an action, and it can turn a choice into a paid job that stops when the payment stops.

From "UI/UX basics", a free course by Venkat R. Murty: https://designervenkat.online/learn/ui-ux/avoid-direct-payments

## What you will learn

Many teams think the fastest way to get people to act is to pay them. Sign up, post a tip, invite a friend or give blood, and the reward is cash, a discount or a gift card. This lesson explains why that often backfires and what to do instead. You will learn the rule called Avoid Direct Payments, the two ideas behind it, and how to choose a better motivator. We will walk through a real app, Duolingo, step by step.

- **Direct payment:** Money, a discount or a gift card given straight to a user for doing an action.
- **Cash equivalent:** Anything that works like money, such as store credit or a voucher that can be spent like cash.
- **Motivation:** The reason a person wants to do something.
- **Intrinsic motivation:** Doing something because it feels worthwhile, interesting or right to you.
- **Extrinsic motivation:** Doing something to get a reward, or to avoid a loss, that comes from outside you.
- **Crowding out:** When an outside reward pushes aside a person's own reasons for acting.
- **Overjustification effect:** When a reward for an activity someone already enjoys makes them enjoy it less.
- **Non-monetary motivator:** A reward that is not money, such as thanks, recognition or a view of progress.
- **Social frame:** The way people understand what a situation is about, such as a favour between neighbours versus a paid job.

## What counts as a direct payment?

A direct payment is a reward that gives a user money, or something that works like money, straight after an action. In a product it often looks like cash back for a referral, a discount code for a review, or a gift card for finishing a survey. The rule does not say every reward is wrong. It asks you to check two things: is money the main reason someone acts, and will they keep going when the money stops?

- **Cash and transfers:** Money sent to a bank account or wallet after an action, such as a fee for signing up or for completing a task.
- **Discounts and credits:** A lower price or store credit given for an action. To the user it still works like money.
- **Gift cards and vouchers:** Cards that can be spent like cash, given for a survey, a referral or a donation.

## Why can paying people backfire?

Most people expect a reward to add motivation. Behavioural research shows the picture is more complicated. Two named effects explain why a payment can leave people doing less once it is gone.

### What is the overjustification effect?

The Decision Lab, a behavioural science reference site, describes the overjustification effect as a drop in interest in an activity after people are rewarded for it. The effect applies to tasks people already enjoy. Frey's paper finds that rewards tied to a task can improve performance on dull tasks.

Shopping apps that hand out points for discounts, or fitness apps that give badges for challenges, show the same risk. Points and badges have their own lesson, so here we focus on cash.

### What is crowding out, where the reward replaces the reason?

Bruno Frey, an economist, uses the term crowding out for a case where an outside reward takes the place of a person's own reason. In his 1994 paper he describes a boy who mowed the family lawn willingly. Once his father offered a fee for each cut, the boy mowed only when he was paid, and would not do other chores for free. The fee did not add effort. It replaced the boy's reason.

Frey gives a second cause as well. An outside reward can send the message that a person's own effort is not valued. When people feel their skill is not acknowledged, they tend to lower their effort.

### When the payment stops

The worst part comes at the end.

> **Tip:** Before you launch a payment, write down what users will do on the first day after it ends. If the honest answer is that the activity stops, you have rented a habit rather than building one.

## How a payment changes the meaning of an action

Frey also argues that money changes the social frame. A favour between neighbours, or a donation, runs on goodwill and shared norms. People help because it is the decent thing to do. Once money is offered, the same act starts to look like a trade, and the person begins to ask whether the amount is worth the trouble.

Frey reports an experiment on giving blood. Before the study, people were asked about donating. One group was then offered cash, and that group was less likely to donate blood than the group that was not offered anything. Frey's reading is that the payment changed what the act meant, and it did not add a reason to give.

If an app pays a set sum for each friend a user invites, the friend becomes a number with a price, and the user may judge the invitation against that sum, even though they first sent it because they thought the friend would enjoy the app.

## What non-monetary motivators can you use instead?

Non-monetary motivators are rewards that are not cash or cash equivalents. The Wikipedia article on incentives lists examples such as recognition, praise, chances to grow and gifts. Ivan Jureta, writing about crowding out, suggests recognition, development opportunities and meaningful feedback as ways to reduce the risk of crowding out.

- **Recognition:** Name the person who did the thing, or thank them in public. A tip credited to its author feels different from a tip that earns a fee.
- **Impact feedback:** Tell the user what their action changed. A message such as 'your tip helped a neighbour find a plumber' keeps attention on the result, not the price.
- **Progress:** Show a visible path, such as completed steps or a count of days, so the user can see effort adding up.
- **Status and belonging:** Show a label that says what kind of helper the user is, and link it to real contribution rather than to a payment.

> **Tip:** Test a reward by imagining it removed. If the user would stop caring the moment it disappeared, the reward was carrying the whole motive, and you should add a reason that does not depend on it.

### Gifts framed as thanks, not fees

Frey notes that cash ties a reward to a specific result, because people learn to link their income with what they produced. A gift in kind, such as flowers, a book or a day out, can be chosen to show that a person's general attitude is valued rather than one result. Frey also warns that prizes given for one particular result can push out motivation, while recognition for long-term commitment can raise it. A thank-you note after a donation fits the second group. A gift card does not.

## Worked example: Duolingo's streak

Duolingo is a language learning app. Instead it uses a streak, which is a count of days in a row on which the learner reaches a daily goal. Follow the screens step by step to see how the design keeps the action feeling like the learner's own.

1. **Let the learner set a goal:** When learners start, the app asks how much time they want to learn each day. Meeting that goal keeps the streak going.
2. **Keep the first step small:** The daily action stays manageable on a busy day.
3. **Celebrate progress on screen:** Milestones are marked with animations, badges and shareable graphics, and the streak count sits where learners see it each time they open the app.
4. **Add a friend layer:** Duolingo's Friend Streak lets learners share a streak with friends.
5. **Check the limits honestly:** So the app is not free of payments. Money can protect a habit, but it can also turn the habit into a sale.

> **Tip:** The same pattern works for blood donation without paying anyone. A service can send a reminder of the next eligible date, a message about what donated blood can do for patients, and a thank-you after each visit. Each item gives meaning and progress, not a fee.

## When is cash still reasonable?

The rule is not a ban. Frey notes that monetary incentives can play a useful role in many areas, including health care, and that a market wage can signal skill rather than only control. A study published in a research journal found that crowding out is less likely when initial motivation is low, and that high-power incentives strongly crowd out people who are already highly motivated.

- **Paid work:** When a person is doing a job for a client, pay is expected and fair. Nobody thinks the work is a favour, so cash is honest here.
- **One-off dull tasks:** A short, tedious task, such as testing a confusing form once, can be paid with a clear fee. State plainly that the fee is for time.
- **Very low starting motivation:** If almost nobody wants to act, a modest payment may start the behaviour. Plan non-money reasons to keep it going after payments end.

> **Tip:** Cash is easiest to defend when you name it: pay for time or for work. A discount disguised as a thank-you makes the price hidden, and hidden prices are harder for users to trust.

## A checklist before you pay

1. **Ask whether people already enjoy it:** If users do the activity for its own sake, such as helping a neighbour, a payment has the most to lose.
2. **Check the relationship:** Frey finds that the more personal the relationship between the people involved, the more a payment can disturb their own motivation. Neighbours and friends are higher risk than anonymous customers.
3. **Choose a non-money reason:** Pick recognition, impact feedback or progress that fits the action, then check with real users that it lands.
4. **Plan the ending:** Decide what keeps the action going when any payment stops. If you cannot name it, reconsider the payment.

## Check yourself

Try these three short scenarios. Each one needs the idea from this lesson to answer.

**Quick check:** A neighbourhood app wants more residents to post helpful tips, so the team proposes paying 0.50 dollars per post. Posting rises for a short time, then both quality and volume drop once the payments are cut. Why did this happen, and what non-monetary change would you try instead?

A. Residents never wanted to post, so the payment only worked for a short while and nothing else could help.
B. The fee turned a neighbourly favour into a small paid task, so when the pay stopped the reason left with it. Try recognition for helpful tips and impact messages that show who each tip helped.
C. Half a dollar is too small to matter, so the drop came from random changes and not from the payment.
D. The app should add more posting screens, because easier posting is the only real motivator.

**Answer:** B. The fee gave residents a price to compare against, so posting became a transaction. Credit for helpful tips, plus feedback on what they did for neighbours, keeps a reason to post after payments end. The other options blame the users or the screens instead of the motive.

**Quick check:** A food bank app wants more volunteers for weekend shifts. One team wants to give a 10 dollar gift card for each shift. Another suggests a thank-you note after each shift, plus a weekly message about the meals the team packed. Which idea fits this lesson best?

A. The gift card, because volunteers who receive money will always come back.
B. The thank-you note and the weekly impact message, with volunteering left unpaid so it stays a choice to help.
C. The gift card for the first month, then remove it without telling anyone.
D. Hide the sign-up button, so fewer people are tempted and the ones who sign up are more serious.

**Answer:** B. A gift card is a cash equivalent, and it would put a price on a volunteer's time. The note and the impact message thank people and show meaning, which is the kind of motivator this lesson recommends.

**Quick check:** A research team needs several people to test a confusing checkout page for one hour each. The task is dull, and the testers are hired for the session rather than volunteering. What should the team do?

A. Pay nothing and rely on the testers' pride in helping improve a product.
B. Pay a clear fee for the hour and name it as pay for time, because this is paid one-off work where cash is expected.
C. Offer a discount code instead of money, because a discount feels less like a transaction.
D. Pay after the test without stating the amount beforehand, so the reward feels like a surprise.

**Answer:** B. This is paid work for a short, dull task, which is the case where cash is expected and honest. A hidden discount or a surprise amount hides the price, and relying on pride ignores that the testers were hired.

## Summary

Avoid direct payments when people already care about the action, or when a payment would turn a favour into a trade. Start with recognition, impact feedback, progress and honest thanks. Keep cash for paid work and for dull one-off tasks, and say plainly what the money is for. Then check how the habit will survive when the last payment ends.

## Sources

- [Bruno S. Frey, 'How Intrinsic Motivation Is Crowded Out and In' (Rationality and Society, 1994)](https://www.bsfrey.ch/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/how-intrinsic-motivation-is-crowded-out-and-in.pdf)
- [The Decision Lab, 'Overjustification Effect'](https://thedecisionlab.com/biases/overjustification-effect)
- [Wikipedia, 'Incentive'](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incentive)
- [Ivan Jureta, 'Crowding-Out Effect: The Wrong Incentives Erode the Right Motives'](https://ivanjureta.com/crowding-out-effect-the-wrong-incentives-erode-the-right-motives/)
- [Designers University, 'Overjustification Effect' (behavioral laws list)](https://www.designers.university/behavioral-laws-list/overjustification-effect)
- [ScienceDirect, 'Don't pay the highly motivated too much' (research article)](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2214804322001422)
- [Duolingo Blog, 'How Streaks keep Duolingo learners committed to their language goals'](https://blog.duolingo.com/how-streaks-keep-duolingo-learners-committed-to-their-language-goals/)
- [Duolingo Blog, 'product lessons friend streak'](https://blog.duolingo.com/product-lessons-friend-streak/)
- [Apptitude, 'App Teardown: How Duolingo's Streak Mechanic Actually Works'](https://apptitude.io/blog/how-duolingos-streak-mechanic-actually-works/)
- [Blake Crosley, 'Duolingo: Gamification as Design Language'](https://blakecrosley.com/guides/design/duolingo)
