Crowd Out Old Habit with New Behavior
Do not just tell people to stop. Give them a new action that fits the same moment the old habit starts.
In short
To crowd out an old habit, give people a new action that fits the same moment the old habit starts, instead of just telling them to stop.
5 min readFree
What you will learn
Most old habits do not end just because you decide to stop. They come back whenever the moment that starts them returns. In this lesson you will learn to crowd out an old habit. You keep the moment that starts it, and you put a new action in its place.
Designers can use the same idea. A screen can make the new action the easy one, right where people already pause.
Key words
- Habit
- An action you repeat so often, in the same setting, that you do it almost without thinking.
- Cue
- A signal that starts a habit, such as a time of day, a place, or something you just did.
- Automatic
- Done without much conscious thought or effort.
- Crowd out
- To fill the space an old habit used, so the old habit has less room.
- Prompt
- A cue that tells a person to act now.
Why do old habits stick?
Researchers Wendy Wood, David Neal, Jennifer Labrecque and Phillippa Lally studied habits in daily life. Their 2011 paper says a habit grows slowly, as a person repeats the same action in the same kind of setting. Strong habits were tied to that setting. A person's current goal had little pull on them.
Settings start habits
A place, a time of day, or an earlier action can set off a habit before you think about it.
Goals can mislead
People often feel that a goal guides their habit. The paper found that the setting does most of the work for strong habits.
Telling people to try harder is weak
The authors note that changing intentions tends to change behavior mainly when the behavior is not yet habitual.
Quick check
In the paper's stadium study, what made habitual stadium-goers speak louder?
What is the crowd-out idea?
To crowd out a habit, keep the cue and change the response. The cue is the signal that starts the habit. The response is what you do next. When a new response takes the old one's place, it begins with the same signal.
Keep the cue, swap the action
Write the habit as one short sentence: when this cue happens, I do this. Then change only the second part. For example, if a user always opens a news feed after lunch, a designer could show a short summary at that same moment.
Tip
Change one thing at a time. That way you can see which change made the difference.
Steps to crowd out a habit
- 1
Name the cue
Write down the time, place, or action that comes right before the old habit.
- 2
Pick a small new action
Choose something that takes only seconds. Small actions are easier to repeat in a busy moment.
- 3
Put it where the old one was
Place the new action on the screen or spot where the old habit starts.
- 4
Make the old path harder
Move or slow down the old action so it takes more effort.
- 5
Repeat in the same setting
Do the new action in the same place each time, and check whether it happens.
Ability and prompts
BJ Fogg's Behavior Model says a behavior happens when motivation, ability, and a prompt come together at the same moment. If one is missing, the behavior does not happen. In crowding out, the old cue works as the prompt. The new action must be easy, which is the ability part.
Why remove the old cue?
Change the setting
Move the trigger, such as an app icon, away from the spot where the habit starts.
Watch the urge
Notice and log each time the old habit starts. The paper names close monitoring of the unwanted action as a useful tactic.
Add friction
Add a few extra taps to the old action. The paper also points to reducing exposure to triggers.
Wood's book reports that laws banning smoking in public spaces changed habits widely, and smoking fell across the nation.
Why give the habit time?
New habits do not form on a fixed schedule. One study of healthy eating, drinking and exercise found that the time for a habit to level off varied from 18 to 254 days.
Quick check
What is the best first step to crowd out a habit?
A tiny model in code
This short program is a toy model. A dictionary links one cue to one response. Crowding out means changing the response and keeping the cue.
habits = {"after coffee": "open the news app"}
print("Before: " + habits["after coffee"])
habits["after coffee"] = "read one tip card"
print("After: " + habits["after coffee"])Output
Before: open the news app After: read one tip card
Key takeaways
Old habits are tied to cues in a setting. You crowd them out by keeping the cue and giving it a new, easy action. Then you make the old path harder and repeat the new one in the same place.
Tip
Design for the moment the old habit starts, not for a general wish to change.
Sources
- Neal, Wood, Labrecque and Lally (2011), How do habits guide behavior? Journal of Experimental Social Psychology (PDF)
- BJ Fogg, Fogg Behavior Model (behaviormodel.org)
- Wikipedia, Habit
- Study of habit formation timing for eating, drinking and exercise (PubMed Central, PMC6302524)
- Good Habits, Bad Habits by Wendy Wood, Apple Books (Publishers Weekly review)
Last updated on 17 November 2026
Related lessons
Learn with me
Every lesson is free. I add new ones as I learn. Have a question, or want help with your own work? Book a short call.