Deploy Peer Comparisons: Show Users How Similar People Act
Learn how to show a user's result beside the results of similar people, when it helps, when it backfires, and how to keep it honest.
In short
A peer comparison shows a user's result beside the results of similar people, which can motivate them but can also backfire if it is not honest.
8 min readFree
What You Will Learn
Many people do not know what normal looks like. A peer comparison shows a user how people like them act, so the user can judge their own choice. In this lesson you will learn what a peer comparison is, the research behind it, how to build one step by step, where it can backfire, and how to keep it honest. The examples come from the energy company Opower, whose home energy reports are one of the best studied uses of this idea.
Key words
- Peer comparison
- A part of a screen that places a user's own result beside the results of similar people.
- Social proof
- The habit of deciding what is right by looking at what other people do. It is one of the principles of persuasion described by the researcher Robert Cialdini.
- Peer group
- The set of similar people a user is compared against.
- Descriptive norm
- A plain fact about what most people actually do, such as how much energy they use.
- Injunctive norm
- A signal about what people approve of or think they should do, such as a happy face for good results.
- Boomerang effect
- When a message pushes people in the wrong direction, so the result moves away from the goal.
- Opt-out
- When a user chooses to stop getting a message or feature.
Why do peers move people?
When a person is unsure what to do, they often look at others first. Cialdini describes social proof as the tendency to decide what is correct by finding out what other people think is correct. It is strongest in two situations: when we do not know what to do, and when the people we watch are like us. Both conditions matter. If we are sure of our answer, we do not need to look around. If the people we see are very different from us, what they do tells us little.
Why do similar peers matter most?
Peers who look like the user carry more weight than famous or distant people. Wikipedia's summary of research on social proof notes that people are more likely to adopt the behaviour of others when they see themselves as similar to those people. Cialdini's guidance is direct: a few credible peers do more than a large, unnamed number. For a designer, this means the peer group must feel real and close to the user's own life.
What does a peer comparison look like?
A good peer comparison has three parts. Each part does a different job, and a strong design uses all three together.
The comparison bar
Show the user's own number next to a number from a similar group. Opower's home energy reports compared each household with about 100 nearby homes of similar size and heating type. The user can see at a glance who uses more and who uses less.
The standing label
Add a short label that tells the user where they sit, such as great, good, or below average. In the Opower study, the great group received two smiley faces, the good group received one, and the below average group first received frowning faces until customer complaints ended that practice.
The next step
Pair the comparison with one useful action. Opower's reports included a set of tips picked for each household, based on its energy use and home profile. The comparison shows the gap, and the tip shows how to close it.
How do you deploy a peer comparison?
Follow these steps when you add a peer comparison to a product. Do them in order.
- 1
Pick one clear behaviour
Choose one action you want more of or less of, such as using less energy, saving money, or finishing a set of tasks. A comparison about many things at once confuses users.
- 2
Build a fair peer group
Choose people who are alike in the ways that change the result. For energy, that means home size and heating type. For a learning app, it might mean the same starting level. Write down the rule so you can explain it later.
- 3
Use one shared unit
Show the user and the peers in the same measure, such as kilowatt-hours per month or lessons completed per week. Mixed units make the comparison hard to trust.
- 4
Show the user's place in plain words
Put the user's number next to the peer number, then add a short label. Keep the words simple. A user should understand the message in a few seconds.
- 5
Add one next step
Give one specific action the user can take right away. A comparison with no next step can leave people feeling bad without knowing what to do.
- 6
Test, then measure
Show the comparison to real users and watch two things: whether the target behaviour changes, and whether people hide, mute, or turn off the feature. Both results matter.
Tip
Place the comparison where the user is already deciding or checking progress, such as a monthly summary, not in a random pop-up. The right moment makes the message feel useful instead of pushy.
Where do peer comparisons go wrong?
A comparison can help the goal, but it can also push people away from it. Two risks matter most: the boomerang effect and the feeling that the comparison is unfair.
What is the boomerang risk?
Allcott's study of Opower's home energy reports tested this risk directly. Many models predicted that households who used less than their neighbours might start using more after seeing the comparison, which is the boomerang effect. The study covered about 600,000 households in the United States and found that the average program cut energy use by 2.0 percent. The heaviest users cut their use by 6.3 percent, while the lightest users cut by only 0.3 percent. The researchers did not find a clear boomerang in this setting, but they did not fully explain why. The heaviest users still cut their use by 6.3 percent, and the study did not show a clear boomerang.
What is the fairness problem?
Users who feel a comparison is unfair often leave. In the Opower study, the most common reason for opting out was the belief that the comparisons were unfair or inaccurate, or that the reports were a waste of resources. Opt-out rates across the programs ranged from 0.1 percent to 3.3 percent. A small number is still a sign that some users stopped trusting the message.
Tip
Let users see how the peer group was built.
How do you keep the comparison honest?
Peer comparisons work because people trust what others do. That trust is only fair when the numbers are real. Cialdini's guidance on ethical use says the key question is whether the evidence is true. Made-up counts, bought reviews, and invented agreement are not persuasion. They are misinformation, and they hit hardest the people who are already unsure.
Use real data
Only show numbers you can prove. If you do not have enough users to form a fair peer group, do not invent one. Say that the group is small, or leave the comparison out.
Name the peer group
Say who the peers are in simple words. Cialdini's guidance favours showing who the people are.
Frame the desired behaviour
Describe the behaviour you want, not the mistake you want to reduce. Cialdini notes that saying many people already do the unwanted thing can make that thing more common.
Check Your Design
Before you ship a peer comparison, ask a few plain questions. Could a user explain who they are being compared with? Would the user still trust the number if it were not flattering? Does the message point toward a clear next step? If the answer is no to any of these, fix the design before you test it on people.
Quick check
Which peer group gives a comparison the most force, according to the research described in this lesson?
Quick check
A product says: 'Most people in your area waste water. What about you?' What is the main risk of this wording?
Key Takeaways
A peer comparison shows users how similar people act, which helps them judge their own choice. Use a fair and named peer group, one shared unit, a clear label, and a single next step. Watch for the boomerang effect and for any sign that users feel the comparison is unfair. Most of all, use only real numbers.
Sources
- Cialdini Institute: Social Proof, Cialdini's Principle of Influence, Explained
- Nielsen Norman Group: Social Proof in UX (video)
- Hunt Allcott, Social Norms and Energy Conservation, Journal of Public Economics (2011), PDF copy
- Allcott, Social norms and energy conservation, ScienceDirect abstract page
- Wikipedia: Social proof
Last updated on 17 November 2026
Related lessons
- UI/UX basicsUse Peer Comparisons: Show People How They Compare With Others Like Them
- UI/UX basicsDeploy Strong Authority on Subject: Show Who Stands Behind the Advice
- UI/UX basicsDeploy Social Proof: Show What Others Do at the Moment of Doubt
- UI/UX basicsPrime User-Relevant Associations: Show Cues That Match What Users Care About
Learn with me
Every lesson is free. I add new ones as I learn. Have a question, or want help with your own work? Book a short call.