Use Peer Comparisons: Show People How They Compare With Others Like Them
Show people how their actions compare with those of similar people, so they judge themselves against a fair norm and choose to keep going or change course.
In short
A peer comparison shows people how their actions compare with similar people, so they judge themselves against a fair norm and choose to keep going or change course.
12 min readFree
What You Will Learn
A peer comparison shows a person how their own behavior or results stack up against people who are similar to them. The person then judges their own actions against that comparison. Used well, it can nudge someone to save energy, walk more, or keep a habit going. Used badly, it can make people feel small and quit. In this lesson you will learn why peer comparisons work, how to design one step by step, and what risks to watch for. You will also see a real example from home energy reports.
Key words
- Peer comparison
- A screen or message that puts a person's result next to the results of people like them.
- Peer group
- The set of other people you compare a user with, such as people of a similar age, place, or skill level.
- Social comparison
- The habit people have of judging themselves by looking at others.
- Descriptive norm
- What most people actually do. It answers the question: what is normal here?
- Injunctive norm
- What people approve of or think they should do. It answers the question: what is good here?
- Boomerang effect
- When a message pushes people in the opposite direction to the one you wanted. For example, someone who was already doing well starts to slack off.
- Anonymized data
- Information with names and other identifying details removed, so no one can be traced from it.
- Benchmark
- A standard or reference point that you measure a result against.
Why do peer comparisons work?
People often do not know if they are doing well. A runner may not know if their pace is good. A household may not know if its power bill is high. When there is no clear measuring stick, people look sideways at others. This idea comes from the social psychologist Leon Festinger, who described it in 1954. He argued that people judge their abilities and opinions by comparing them with others, especially others who are similar to them.
They want to know what is normal
A peer comparison gives a descriptive norm. It tells the user what similar people typically do, so the user can see whether their own level is typical, low, or high.
They want to know what is good
A bare average does not say whether a high or low number is the right direction. Adding an approval signal, such as a happy face or a 'great job' label, tells the user which direction is good. This is the injunctive part of the message.
They want to close the gap
When someone sees they are behind a typical peer, they often feel a pull to catch up. That pull is the motivating force behind most peer comparisons.
Good designers keep three facts in mind. People compare most with people they see as similar. People also use comparison to protect how they see themselves, not only to improve. And the same comparison can motivate one person and discourage another. The next sections show how to use these facts.
Comparison works in both directions. Researchers call a comparison with someone better than you an upward comparison, and a comparison with someone worse off a downward comparison. An upward comparison can inspire a person who feels the gap is small enough to close. The same comparison can make someone who feels far behind give up. A downward comparison can make a person feel good, but it can also make them complacent, meaning too comfortable to keep trying.
Tip
Before you add a comparison, ask: will this person see the gap as closeable? If the answer is no, the comparison may discourage them.
Worked Example: Opower Home Energy Reports
The clearest example comes from home energy reports sent by Opower, a company that worked with electric utilities. The reports were printed letters, and later they were also used in other formats. Each report showed a household how its electricity use compared with that of nearby homes of similar size, and it included tips for saving energy. A large study by the economist Hunt Allcott looked at many households across many utilities in the United States. The study found that the reports cut electricity use by a small but real amount on average.
- 1
Step 1: Collect the usage data
Utilities read each home's electricity meter on a regular schedule. The readings were sent to Opower, where each household's comparison was calculated.
- 2
Step 2: Choose a fair peer group
Each household was compared with nearby homes that had similar characteristics, such as similar size and the same heating type. A home with gas heat was not compared with a home with electric heat.
- 3
Step 3: Show the comparison at the top
The first page of the report began with a simple bar chart. It showed the household's own use next to the average of its peer group and a group of especially efficient neighbors. The chart was placed first, so it was the first thing the reader saw.
- 4
Step 4: Add a standing label with a friendly icon
Next to the chart, each household received a label that showed how it compared with its peers. Households doing well received a smiley face as a sign of approval. This small icon told the reader which direction was good, even if the chart alone did not.
- 5
Step 5: Add action tips
The report then listed energy-saving tips. Some were small habit changes, such as turning off lights. Others were bigger purchases, such as a new appliance. The tips were chosen based on each household's usage pattern.
- 6
Step 6: Measure the result with a fair test
Opower and its partners randomly split households into a group that got reports and a group that did not. Comparing the two groups showed the true effect of the reports, not just a general drop in usage.
What should you notice? The design did not just show a number. It gave a peer group, a visual bar, an approval icon, and a next step. Each part does a job. The bar answers what is normal, the icon answers what is good, and the tips answer what to do next. This is a useful pattern to copy in any product.
Tip
A comparison without a next step can leave people feeling judged. Always pair the comparison with something the user can do.
How do you design a peer comparison well?
A good peer comparison has three parts: a relevant peer group, a simple display at the right moment, and a frame that encourages action rather than shame. Work through these three parts in order when you plan a new comparison. Each part has its own short section below.
How do you pick a fair peer group?
A peer group is fair when the people in it could really do what the user does. Festinger's idea is that people compare most with those who are similar to them. So choose peers who match on the things that change behavior, such as age range, location, home type, or skill level. A beginner should be compared with other beginners, not with experts. In the Opower study, the peer group was local and matched on house size and heating type. Researchers also found that people can stop trusting a comparison when they think it is unfair or inaccurate. A poor peer group can cost you users.
When should you show it?
Put the comparison where the decision or the feedback happens. In a weekly summary, show it on the summary screen. After a user finishes a session, show it on the finish screen. Keep the display short. One simple chart with one clear label is easier to understand than a long table. The Opower report placed its comparison first on the page, so readers saw it before anything else. Ask yourself what the user is doing at that moment, and show the comparison when it can change that choice.
How do you frame it so it motivates?
Pair the average with a target
Show the peer average and a goal, such as 'the most efficient peers' level'. A target gives the user something to aim for, not just a number to feel bad about.
Add an approval marker
Use a clear sign of approval, such as a smiley or a short thank-you, for the good result. This tells the user which direction is right, which a bare average does not.
Show the user's own trend
Compare the user with their own past week as well as with peers. If the user is improving, the trend shows progress even when they are still behind the average.
Be gentle with the gap
For someone far behind, show a small first step rather than the full distance. A message like 'a small change this week moves you closer' is easier to act on than a large red number.
Tip
Test your peer group with real users before you launch. Ask people if the comparison feels fair. If many say it does not, change the group before you change the colors.
What are the risks and ethics?
Peer comparisons can help people, but they can also harm them. Designers have a duty to notice the costs. Four risks matter most.
The boomerang effect
Some people move away from the goal because the comparison shows them they are already doing well enough. Those above the peer average may slack off.
Demotivation for people far behind
A user who sees that they are far below everyone else may decide the goal is out of reach and stop trying.
Privacy
A comparison can reveal more about a person than they meant to share. Showing real names, exact locations, or detailed results can expose people to unwanted attention.
Accuracy
A comparison built on bad or unfair data can mislead users and damage trust. If users believe the numbers are wrong, many will stop using the product or ask to stop receiving the comparison.
The boomerang effect deserves a closer look. Social psychologists use this term when a message pushes people the wrong way. In the energy studies, households that used more than their neighbors tended to cut back. But in Ayres et al.'s study, some households that already used less than the average began to use more over time. Allcott found that the Great/Good/Below Average categories had no significant causal effect, and he attributed the lack of a boomerang to the energy tips or to injunctive features that affect all groups equally. The lesson is simple: a bare average can pull good performers down, so always pair it with a clear approval message.
Privacy and data need care too. The designers used pseudonyms (made-up names), avatars, and general demographic groups (groups based on traits such as age or place) instead of real identities. You can use the same approach. Show a peer average, not a list of named neighbors. Use only the data the user has agreed to share, and remove names and exact details from anything that is shown or stored.
Tip
Ask three questions before launch: Is the peer group fair? Does every result come with a clear next step? Can any person be identified from what is shown? If you cannot answer yes to all three, do not ship yet.
Check Your Understanding
Try these two short scenarios. Each one needs the ideas from this lesson to answer.
Quick check
A fitness app shows each user's weekly steps next to the average of all users worldwide. Beginners say they feel discouraged and stop opening the app. What should you change about the comparison, and why?
Quick check
A utility app tells a household that it uses less electricity than most homes in its area. The app shows a plain bar chart and nothing else. The household is already well below the average. What is the main risk, and what is a good fix?
Key Takeaways
Compare with the right people
Use a peer group that is similar in the things that change behavior. A fair group is the foundation of the whole comparison.
Show it when it matters
Place the comparison where the user is making a choice, keep it short, and give one clear next step.
Frame it to motivate
Pair the average with a target and an approval signal. Show progress over time, and make the gap feel closeable.
Protect people and the truth
Watch for the boomerang effect and for people who fall far behind. Use accurate data, and remove identifying details.
A peer comparison is a simple tool with a strong effect. Used with care, it helps people see what is normal and what is good, and it gives them a reason to act. Used carelessly, it can push good performers off track and drive struggling users away. Design it with the user's dignity and privacy in mind from the start.
Sources
- Allcott, Social norms and energy conservation, Journal of Public Economics (2011), PDF copy
- Allcott, Social norms and energy conservation, ScienceDirect abstract page
- Experiment Society: Opower Home Energy Reports summary
- Tools of Change: Opower's Home Energy Report, Minnesota case study
- NBER Working Paper 15386: Positive Energy and Opower peer comparison experiments (Ayres, Raseman, Shih)
- Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab: Reducing energy and water use through information and social comparisons
- Becisions Behavioral Science Dictionary: Boomerang effect
- The Decision Lab: Social Comparison Theory
- EBSCO Research Starters: Social comparison theory
- TESU Introduction to Social Psychology: Social Comparison
- Positive Psychology: Social Comparison Theory and real-life examples
- PMC: The Influence of Social Comparison and Peer Group Size on Risky Decision-Making
- PMC: Social Comparison Effects on Academic Self-Concepts, Which Peers Matter Most?
- arXiv: OtherTube, exchanging YouTube recommendations with strangers (social comparison and privacy)
Last updated on 17 November 2026
Related lessons
- UI/UX basicsDeploy Peer Comparisons: Show Users How Similar People Act
- UI/UX basicsGoal Trackers: Show People How Close They Are to Done
- UI/UX basicsDeploy Social Proof: Show What Others Do at the Moment of Doubt
- UI/UX basicsDecision-Making Support: Help Users Compare Options and Choose With Confidence
Learn with me
Every lesson is free. I add new ones as I learn. Have a question, or want help with your own work? Book a short call.